The Smaller Harms of Lord of the Flies
“Ralph wept for the end of innocence, the darkness of man’s heart, and the fall through the air of the true, wise friend called Piggy.”
William Golding, Lord of the Flies
We think of innocence as that time before. It’s before we understand that the world is full of confusion, selfishness, and people trying to do the right thing but it ends up wrong.
But that’s only part of the story because innocent comes from the Latin in- (not) and nocere (to harm).
To be innocent is, at its root, to be not harming.
That makes Ralph’s grief much stranger and more interesting. Were the boys innocent because they were children? Did they lose it when they first intended harm, when they participated in it, or when they learned what they were all capable of doing? Was Piggy innocent? Was Simon? Was Ralph?
And if innocence means not harming, what do we do with all the softer ways the boys harm one another long before the novel gives us a body?
There’s something else right in that line — his wise friend called Piggy. Because Ralph is the one firstly responsible for Piggy being called a nickname he wanted to leave behind, and in the end he has to reach for this hurtful nickname when he remembers his “wise friend.”
This is the kind of rabbit hole I love.
Fall Through the Air
And what about that “fall through the air”? This is syntactically interesting, no? Piggy is not the head noun, and the focus is on the falling and not what happened after. And Roger is completely absent from the sentence. “Piggy” is buried in that final modifying phrase.
the fall
through the air
of the true, wise friend
called Piggy
Almost as if it just happened.
But there was another fall through the air. The boys’ descent onto the island is a fall they did not choose, produced by a war they did not begin and forces they had no agency to control.
And then we have The Fall. The original loss of innocence.
There is no mention of Simon here. Ralph has previously named Simon’s death as murder, but Simon is absent from this final catalogue of loss. Piggy’s death can appear as something Ralph witnessed and survived. Remembering Simon would also require remembering the violence in which Ralph participated.
The choice in abstraction here.
When Did Innocence End?
When we think of loss of innocence, we might be tempted to look deeper in the novel, several chapters deep. Golding sets us up for this read when the boys invoke Coral Island as the world they plan to inhabit. Ralph insists they will have fun here.
Published in 1857, R. M. Ballantyne’s The Coral Island strands three British boys (Ralph, Jack, and Peterkin…sound familiar?) on a tropical island. The boys remain cooperative, resourceful, Christian, and thoroughly civilized. They do not need adults to impose order because British character supposedly travels with them. Even without the institutions of civilization these “properly raised British boys” will reproduce them.
But the innocence of The Coral Island depends partly on which harms the story recognizes. Its colonial worldview places savagery outside the British boys, in racist depictions of Indigenous people whose cultures can be conquered, corrected, or converted without disturbing the boys’ status as heroes. Harm exists in the story, but British authority is presented as the solution rather than one of its sources.
Golding keeps the names Ralph and Jack but turns so much of the framework from Ballantyne’s novel on its head.
That makes the language of the fall all the more interesting. For Ballantyne’s version to hold, we have to keep looking away from the violence of colonialism. The British boys can remain civilized heroes only because the harm surrounding them does not quite count as theirs.
In Golding’s version, the boys try to reconstruct a civilized and orderly life. They try, and fail. Hard.
When do the boys cause harm? How does humiliation, callousness, arrogance, and selfishness cause harm? How do these smaller choices lead to that final scene of Ralph weeping on the beach?
Golding’s final sentence makes a similar move on the level of language. The violence is there, but the sentence keeps directing our eyes slightly away from it.
Directing Our Eyes Slightly Away
At the end of the novel, on the beach, the naval officer performs the very act the novel has been worrying over. Confronted by the boys’ grief, he looks away. His eyes rest on the “trim cruiser” waiting offshore: the orderly, civilized instrument of a much larger war.
What happens after the loss of innocence?
After five years serving in the Royal Navy during World War II, Golding went back to the normal life of teaching. Like Ralph, Golding lived through an experience that destroyed his belief that civilized people are naturally protected from becoming violent.
Teach Lord of the Flies Alongside Me
I love the moment when one small piece of information rearranges a familiar passage. I love chasing a word backward, putting two scenes beside each other, arguing with an interpretation I have taught before, and realizing that a question I have been asking students is not quite the question I want anymore.
I also love talking about all of this with other English teachers, especially the ones who do not need another person to explain that the conch represents order.
So I’m making a place for us to do that. 🙂
As you move through the novel, I’ll send you the research tangents, teaching stories, close-reading discoveries, questions, audio, video, and occasional classroom materials I would want to pass across the table if we were planning beside each other.
