Victor Frankenstein Writes Himself Out of the Sentence

Early in Frankenstein, before he has built anything, Victor is telling Walton how his ruin began, and he writes this line:

“Destiny was too potent, and her immutable laws had decreed my utter and terrible destruction.”

When we read it again we notice who is doing things. Destiny is potent. Her laws decree. Victor shows up only at the very end, as “my destruction,” a possessive hanging off the object of the sentence. He is narrating the most consequential stretch of his own life, and he has built it so that he is not the one who acts.

That kind of noticing is what I am after when I ask students to analyze the syntax of a passage, and it is almost never what comes back. At best I get commas. A student finds the comma, tells me it marks a pause, and that is about where syntax analysis stops, not because they can’t do more but because “analyze the syntax” hands them a scavenger hunt for punctuation instead of a question to ask the sentence.

So I started from the other end, from what I would actually want them doing, which is the thing Victor’s sentence invites: read the construction as a choice, and read the choice for what it means. A grammatical choice is a choice, and reading it is analysis. Students can do this. What they are usually missing is the question.

The surface and what’s under it

A sentence works on two levels at once, and reading it well means reading both.

On the surface, a sentence arranges power. Somebody acts, somebody is acted upon, one idea takes the main clause while another gets tucked beneath it. Even the flattest sentence has made those decisions, and none of them is neutral. That surface layer is the grammar of agency, and the question it answers is who holds power in the sentence.

Under the surface, a sentence manages its distance from the truth. It decides whether it is stating a fact, supposing a possibility, wishing for something that is not so, or slipping a second thought in beside the main one. This is the layer where a writer keeps something back, or holds it at arm’s length, or lets it in sideways. That is the grammar of interiority and interruption, and the question it answers is what the sentence is doing beneath or beside what it actually says.

Those two layers are close to what a sentence is: an arrangement of power on top, and a management of reality underneath. So much of what a writer does inside a single sentence is one of those two things, which is why two questions are enough to carry a whole year of close reading.

The grammar of agency

Start on the surface, where the power is arranged in plain sight: who acts in this sentence, and who is acted upon?

English gives a writer a lot of room to answer that.

  • Passive voice can make the person doing something optional, so “mistakes were made” never has to say by whom.
  • A voice shift can move the actor offstage in the middle of a passage.
  • Coordination and subordination decide which idea gets the main clause and which one gets tucked underneath it, and that ranking is an argument about what matters, made in grammar instead of in a claim.

Let’s go back to Victor’s sentence with that question in hand. The subjects are Destiny and her immutable laws. The verbs, was and decreed, belong to them. Victor could have written “I destroyed myself,” or “I made a choice I could not take back,” but instead he wrote a sentence where the acting is done by a personified force and he is only the thing it was done to. A man narrating his own catastrophe reached for the grammar that let him stand beside it rather than inside it.

A student who notices that Victor keeps handing the verbs to fate has found, in the syntax, the exact evasion the novel spends the rest of its length dramatizing.

Grammar as a Reading Tool Freebie Banner

Free text-by-text curriculum map

Bring grammar back into the reading.

Text-by-Text Grammar Map

See how passive voice, verb mood, clause structure, and other grammatical choices can become close-reading tools across the texts you already teach.

Includes a grades 9–11 progression, text pairings, reading questions, and a planning page.

Get the Free Map

The grammar of interiority and interruption

Now drop under the surface. The second question is quieter, and it looks past who acts to what the sentence is doing beneath what it presents. Sometimes a sentence steps outside what is real. Sometimes it slips a second thought in beside the main one. The moves here are verb mood, conditional mood, the grammar of the unreal, and the appositives and parentheticals that interrupt a sentence to reframe it.

Mood is the center of it. A sentence in the indicative states what is. A conditional describes a world that only exists if some condition is met. The subjunctive reaches for what is wished, required, or imagined but not true. When a writer changes mood, they change their relationship to reality, and a reader who can hear the shift can hear what the writer is doing with it.

Here is the creature, later in the book, making his case to Victor for a companion:

“If you consent, neither you nor any other human being shall ever see us again.”

Nothing in that sentence has happened. The whole peaceful future it describes, the exile to South America and the vanishing from human sight, exists only inside the word if. And the condition that unlocks it is Victor’s to meet. So the creature has done something precise with the grammar of possibility. He has built a world where the good ending is entirely available and entirely Victor’s to grant, which quietly makes the bad ending, if it comes, Victor’s fault. The conditional is where that pressure lives. Reading it is reading who holds the terms in the room.

That, again, is grammar being analysis. The creature is doing more than asking. He is using mood to move the moral weight onto the person he is asking.

Grammar for Literary Analysis | Blog Ad Block

Make the sentence-level thinking visible

Grammar for Literary Analysis

The Grammar as a Reading Tool framework

Move grammar out of isolation and into the texts students are already reading. These 17 connected lessons help students use syntax, voice, mood, and sentence structure as evidence in close reading.

  • 9 concept-based lessons
  • 8 character application lessons
  • Student notes and teaching slides
  • Printable reference materials
Explore the Resource on TPT

A small set of moves, used all year

What makes this teachable is that it is not many moves: two questions, and a short list under each that a student carries from one text to the next. That is the opposite of relearning grammar as a fresh unit every fall.

The read is the same each time. Notice the move. Name what it is doing in this sentence. Then trace it, because a writer who reaches for passive voice once usually reaches for it again, and the pattern is where the deeper reading is. Early on, a student might catch only the single sentence. Later, they follow the move across a chapter and build a claim about the book on it. It is the same lens, only with more pressure on it.

And it travels, because every writer worth teaching is arranging power on the surface and managing reality underneath. The move in Victor’s fatalism is the move in a politician’s “mistakes were made.” The conditional the creature uses to corner Victor is the conditional in any threat or any seduction, in whatever text your students pick up next.

Teaching Grammar as a Reading Tool

One thought on “Teaching Grammar as a Reading Tool”

  • July 22, 2026 at 12:39 pm
    Permalink

    This just took me to church! I’m always humbled at how well you articulate the exact thing I’m struggling to get at in thinking about how I want to approach a text with students.

    Reply

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

css.php Skip to content